And, Switzerland is a country that has very strong unity and economic functionality. French, German, Italian and Romansh. Though this amendment died in Congress, it reappeared in various iterations over time, passing the House inand finding Senate approval 10 years later, as part of an immigration reform bill that itself failed to become law.
Both the languages are historical in origin and should be continued in the same pattern. Englishthe following states have existing official language laws on their books: Even at home front, English is more acceptable in the southern part of the country than the national language Hindi.
India got independence inbut is still following the law formulated by the then English government and the language of the office. There are advantages and disadvantages to creating an official language.
This would unreasonably burden government services, adding a huge layer of bureaucracy and costs. Here is the text of a proposed amendment. Suggesting that learning English is easy for some races and difficult for other races is, itself, racist. The Beijing dialect of Mandarin and Guangzhou dialect of Cantonese were each proposed as the basis for a national language for China.
For example, John Tanton, the founder of the main political lobbying organization in this movement called US English, had to resign in after making derogatory remarks about Hispanics. Here as elsewhere, people who are isolated by language tend — much like poor people, or victims of sexual assault, for example — to get blamed for their condition.
One prerequisite of being an American, as we have seen, is the ability to speak English. Yes Sorry, something has gone wrong. Such thinking feeds directly into a more basic question of US identity: We wear the masks we think other people want to see.
Before it's independence, after the collation of the Moghuls the British became the rulers of north India. They aimed at creating a breed of such individuals who are Indian by blood and colour but English by taste and opinion. Since then, the Beijing dialect has become the main standard for pronunciation, due to its prestigious status during the preceding Qing Dynasty.
I know, it's wikipedia, but take it with a grain of salt, and consider the views above to me by own. This is a bad combination in public policy; a right that cannot be provided adequately that nevertheless adds billions of dollars in extra costs for US government and taxpayers.
Proficiency in English is crucial to successful cultural assimilation in the United States. Overall, making English as a second national language will be beneficial for local people in India and for foreigners.
But that status is still pending and the transformation has yet to be made. Often these bills are in response to legislation recognizing non-English languages in public discourse of some kind.
There are about languages spoken in the United States - some, like Spanish, by a lot of people, and others, like some Native American dialects, by literally a handful. Performed with ease or clumsiness, awareness or not, guile or good faith, it is none the less something that must be enacted and portrayed, something that must be realized.Geopolitical history demonstrates the authoritarian bent of one-language policies, as well as their inability to produce greater nationalistic cohesion, as is so often their stated purpose.
Should English be the Official Language of the United States Name ENG Instructor April 30, Should English be the Official Language of the United States The debate on whether the United States should make English the official language has been raging.
The ACLU, which is part of a group opposed to establishing a national official language, has published a paper detailing reasons that such a move should be opposed. It starts by mentioning an effort by John Adams, into establish an official academy devoted to English, a move which was rejected at the time as undemocratic.
A push for English to be the official language of the US has both a dark history and a regressive vision for the future Why would the USA make English an official language? | Aeon Essays It’s our 6th birthday! Debate whether or not English should be the official language of the United States.
Voice your opinion, and learn about each side of the debate. Should English be the official language of the United States? Add a New Topic; Add to My Favorites Yes, English should be the national language of America. Its so obvious that English is the.
Dec 31, · If we are going to be a united people, people who understand each other and can work together with people from anywhere in the country, we will have to have an official national language.Download